Notes on Issues in the Interpretation of the Decalogue
How (and why) count ten in the list?
-
Is recognizing God independent of not having other gods?
-
Are other gods and sculpted images the same thing?
-
Are women property?
-
Judaism counts Exodus 20:2 as the first commandment, 20:3-6 as the second commandment, and 20:14 as the tenth commandment.
-
Catholicism counts Exodus 20:3-4 as the first commandment, 20:7 as the second commandment, and 20:14 as the ninth and tenth commandments.
-
Reform protestants count Exodus 20:3 as the first commandment, 20:4 as the second commandment, and 20:14 as the tenth commandment.
-
Who cares? What about crucifixes?
How many on each tablet?
-
All agree there are two tablets, one about relationship with God, another about relationship with neighbor.
- Judaism counts 5 and 5
- Catholicism counts 3 and 7
- Reform protestants count 4 and 6
What other gods are there to be jealous of?
-
Henotheism – having one god for oneself, but acknowledging the existence of other gods
(cf. being devoted to the Spurs but acknowledging the existence of other teams)
-
Monotheism – only one god exists
(the Lakers do not exist)
- Pure monotheism does not appear in Israelite literature before Second Isaiah
-
The position that the idea of monotheism developed over time and is not always assumed in the Bible is a good example of modern (not early) biblical interpretation.
Transgenerational punishment
-
Does God visit the guilt of parents upon the children, upon the third and fourth generations of those who reject God?
-
Another good example of historical development in legal interpretation
-
See sources on transgenerational punishment in chronological sequence
(PDF)